Concerns of Parents of Lesbians and Gays: Interview with Cynthia Conley, Ph.D.


Risk for suicide among gay youth has caught a lot of attention in the American media as of late. There have been a number of youth who have been bullied because they have been gay or perceived to be gay and who have consequently died by suicide. Dan Savage and friends and colleagues and supporters have put together an amazing project called "It Gets Better" (http://www.itgetsbetterproject.com/) focusing on the issue of youth suicide for gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender, question and queer teens.

Now there is good reason for this. According to the U.S. Government’s Report of the Secretary's Task Force on Youth Suicide, gay and lesbian youth bear an increased risk of suicide, substance abuse, school problems, and isolation because of a "hostile and condemning environment, verbal and physical abuse, rejection and isolation from [peers and family]" (Gibson, 1989). Social worker and pioneer gay and lesbian researcher Caitlin Ryan, found that lesbian, gay, and bisexual young adults who reported higher levels of family rejection during adolescence were 8.4 times more likely to report having attempted suicide, 5.9 times more likely to report high levels of depression, 3.4 times more likely to use illegal drugs, and 3.4 times more likely to report having engaged in unprotected sexual intercourse compared with peers from families that reported no or low levels of family rejection (Ryan, Huebner, Diaz, & Sanchez, 2009).

So, here’s the thing. Families who reject their kids are doing their kids a huge disservice. And that’s the point of today’s podcast. Today I’m talking with Dr. Cynthia Conley about the concerns of heterosexual parents of gay and lesbian youth.

Cynthia Conley, Ph.D. is Assistant Professor in the Department of Social Work at Ball State University in Muncie, Indiana. Her research focuses on parental concerns about having gay and lesbian children. Currently, Professor Conley is investigating the types of clinical interventions used with heterosexual parents of gay and lesbian children to develop a best practice model to improve family cohesion during the coming out crisis. Professor Conley has worked with LGBT adolescents and their parents since the late 1990s, focusing on heterosexual parent’s acceptance of their LGBT children. She provides consultation to organizations, educational institutions, and service providers on working with families of LGBT children. She received her B.A. from Purdue University, her MSW from Indiana University, and her Ph.D. from the University of Louisville.

So here’s the pop quiz for you: When lesbian or gay youth come out to their parents, what concerns are their parents most likely to have? Well, I’m not going to answer - you’ll have to listen to the podcast for that. And I hope you like it. So, on to episode 62 of the Social Work Podcast, Concerns of Parents of Gays and Lesbians: An Interview with Dr. Cynthia Conley.

Download MP3 [26:54]



Contact Info:
Cynthia Conley, Ph.D., MSW
Assistant Professor
Department of Social Work
Ball State University
Fine Arts Building, Rm. 227C
Muncie, Indiana 47306
765-285-1019
email address removed due to hate mail


Transcript
Jonathan Singer: Cyndi, thanks so much for being here today and, talking with us about how to talk to parents, who have gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender, or questioning teens.

Cynthia Conley: Thank you Jonathan, I appreciate the opportunity to come in and, talk about this topic.

Jonathan Singer: I know it’s a significant focus of your research, and, and I’m very excited about this conversation because, there’s been a lot of information out there about, LGBTQ, individuals, but there’s not much out there about the parents is there?

Cynthia Conley: You are, you’re very correct about that, there is, there’s a huge gap, and as you said it that’s, this is my, primary research topic I’m very passionate about, really trying to help families, who have gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender children, I just really want to continue my research and, really investigating, the concerns or the experiences that parents have when, they learn about their children’s sexual orientations, or their gender identities.

Jonathan Singer: So let me ask you a question, I’m sitting at my office, I get a phone call, I’m in an agency, I’m at a hospital, I’m somewhere, and parent calls up and they say I’m, I’m freaking out, I think my kid might be gay.

Cynthia Conley: Um hm

Jonathan Singer: What do I do with that?

Cynthia Conley: Sure, well you know of course as, as any good practitioner would do is address the, feelings first and, in my practice and my research experience, you know I found that there are three dominant concern areas, that parents experience, when they learn that their children are gay or lesbian. One of the, the dominant areas is around, their own feelings of, the loss of loved ones, so, parents experience, concern that they may, lose friends, if their friends find out that they have a gay or lesbian child, parents are very much concerned about, that their loved ones will avoid them, if they find out, and so, as a practitioner you can address, you know the specific area by asking, you know when your son or daughter, came out as gay or lesbian to what extent, you know were or are you concerned you may lose friends, you know, and you can certainly have the parent then, you know say well, you can have them rank order it, you know, on a scale of 1 to 5, you know 1 being not concerned at all to, 5 being extremely concerned, to understand the level of concern that parent is experiencing in that particular area. So love loss is one, particular area of parents’ concern.

Jonathan Singer: So for this, hypothetical parent that calls me, one of the things that I need to keep in mind is that, one of their reactions might be, how’s this going to affect me?

Cynthia Conley: Yes

Jonathan Singer: How, how’s this going to affect my social life, how’s this going to affect the way that people think of me as a parent, maybe I’m going to lose my friends, maybe my family’s going to reject me...

Cynthia Conley: Yes

Jonathan Singer: ...because my kid is gay.

Cynthia Conley: Right. Yeah, and you can really kind of, categorize this as internal, versus external, concerns. Internal concerns as far as, you know, oh my gosh, what’s the outside world, what’s society going to think of me? And then there’s the external concerns, oh my gosh, I have concerns for, my child’s physical, psychological, and social well-being. So, if you want to look at internal concerns versus external concerns, that’s certainly, one helpful way of looking at, this issues.

Jonathan Singer: So what are some of the - you said that there were three ways of, of thinking about this...

Cynthia Conley: Sure

Jonathan Singer: ...three areas.

Cynthia Conley: So, you know the next you know dominant, area of concern is really, parents’ concerns for their, physical, psychological, and social well-being. They’re very concerned about, you know whether or not, their child will be physically assaulted, whether they will be verbally assaulted, they are, very concerned as to whether their child’s self-esteem will suffer, as a result of belonging to a stigmatized group, as well as their social well-being, you know, will my child makes friends, because, they are gay or lesbian, will my child have equal civil rights, because they are gay or lesbian. So, those three areas you can, you can certainly again, you know, ask questions of the parents in the same kind of format, you know, are you concerned, you know now that your child has come out or, you believe that your child is gay or lesbian, you know you could certainly ask questions around, you know this area, are you concerned that, they will be physically assaulted, are you concerned that they will not receive good health care. So, these are the kinds of questions that, can certainly tap into the physical, and again you know the psychological, concern for the psychological well-being, you could ask them, you know are you concerned that, you know your child’s self-esteem will be okay, that, they will be proud about who they are, and then again the social, aspects as far as, the concerns, you can ask that, you know are you concerned that your child will not, have equal civil rights, those are three areas within, the dominant area of child well-being.

Jonathan Singer: Okay so, let me just make sure I, I’m understanding, so the first area would be this love loss,

Cynthia Conley: Love loss, right.

Jonathan Singer: and that’s,

Cynthia Conley: I’m afraid I’m going to lose friends.

Jonathan Singer: I’m afraid I’m going to lose friends, there’s going to be so love loss for me.

Cynthia Conley: Yes, I’m afraid my neighbors are going to reject me, and I’m afraid that, yes my loved ones will avoid me.

Jonathan Singer: And then the second area is, it’s not about the parent it’s, it’s really that parenting,

Cynthia Conley: Yes, it’s external.

Jonathan Singer: yeah, it’s my concern for my child,

Cynthia Conley: Child well-being.

Jonathan Singer: is somebody going to beat up my kid?

Cynthia Conley: Yes

Jonathan Singer: You know, the hate crimes,

Cynthia Conley: Yes

Jonathan Singer: is there going to be some you know, now my kid won’t be able to, have equal protection under the law,

Cynthia Conley: Right

Jonathan Singer: that sort of thing, okay,

Cynthia Conley: Yep

Jonathan Singer: good I’m getting it, and what’s the third area of concern?

Cynthia Conley: Okay, and then the third area, which is you could say that it’s somewhat related to the love loss, that public perception, area is, concerns about society’s perception, of them as parents, so almost like this social desirability, so, you know are you concerned that, you will be judged a parenting failure by society, because your child is gay or lesbian? Are you, concerned that, your child is gay or lesbian because you did not spend enough time with them, as a parent, all of these types of items, speak to, oh my gosh, what is society going to think about me, if I didn’t do these things and my kid is gay, or lesbian? Okay, what are people going to think about me, the gaze is upon them.

Jonathan Singer: No pun intended.

Cynthia Conley: Yes that’s right, that’s right.

Jonathan Singer: [chuckling] So the third area is really, society’s perception

Cynthia Conley: Yes

Jonathan Singer: of, the parent,

Cynthia Conley: Yes

Jonathan Singer: because your kid is gay, you must have screwed up as a parent.

Cynthia Conley: Yes, yes

Jonathan Singer: Which is different than, because your kid is gay I no longer want to be your friend.

Cynthia Conley: Yes

Jonathan Singer: Right, okay, I get it! And, all of those seem to be, totally, reasonable concerns,

Cynthia Conley: Yes

Jonathan Singer: that a parent would have, to say, will my friends reject me? Will my kid get hurt? And will people think of me as a failure as a parent?

Cynthia Conley: That’s right, I mean and the parents you know they experience the effects of, the stigma surrounding homosexuality, just like their children do, you know the parents certainly, experience what is coined as, “courtesy stigma”, by the work of a sociologist, Erving Goffman, and um, there’s you know, little research out there that really studies these ill effects that the parents experience, and there’s you know, relatively, few supports, you know for these parents, you know there’s a lot of, knowledge to be built in this area, through practice and research.

Jonathan Singer: So let’s say that, I’m talking with a parent, and I have these three areas in my mind, and a parent is talking about say, I’m totally freaking out because, you know my grandfather’s birthday’s coming up and I know that if he finds out, he’s gonna totally disown me, and, he’s not going to want to have anything to do with my son, and it’s just it’s going to tear the family apart.

Cynthia Conley: Um hm

Jonathan Singer: Is there something specific that I should say in response, or can I just use, my clinical skills, to address it in the way that I am, trained or most comfortable.

Cynthia Conley: There’s really so little known , in this area that, you know I can give you, kind of a code book response, you know to this, you know however I, the parents, are going to experience again, the, similar notion of coming out, just like their children, um

Jonathan Singer: Like the parents have to come out

Cynthia Conley: The parents have to come out as well

Jonathan Singer: to society, as a parent,

Cynthia Conley: Yes

Jonathan Singer: of a kid who is

Cynthia Conley: That’s right, the parents have to come out, and um, you know, so they have their own coming out experience as much like their children. You know as a practitioner, you know if I were to, address that question, certainly I would not advise, that parent, to come out, okay? I mean I would, I’m not going to advise a client to come out, they have to be ready

Jonathan Singer: They have to want to come out.

Cynthia Conley: and they have to want to come out and there, this is a process, just like the identity development, of their, LGBT children, there’s an identity development process for parents, of LGBT children, and they have to work through this, I mean it’s a journey, and, um, you know, I would, you know certainly as a clinician, I would explore the feelings around that, you know, I’m afraid of this, of coming out to my, you know, my parents and what they’re going to think about, you know me for having a gay or lesbian child and, you know I’d advise them they’ll you know, it’s okay, for you to not reveal this information until you’re ready, as a clinician I would focus on the feelings, her feelings of concern, or her feelings of anxiety.

Jonathan Singer: So I can see how this, would be, really useful, when talking with a parent. I’m wondering if you think, it would be useful to talk to, the child, if you happen to have that type of relationship with a kid whose thinking of coming out or has come out to you but not come out to, his or her parent, um, to talk to them, about well these are some things that your parents might be concerned about.

Cynthia Conley: Sure, sure, and I think it would be very beneficial to, an LGBT client, to have this information, if they have not come out to their parents, they can, use this information to guide conversations with their parents, you know depending on the strength of that relationship, you know the LGBT child or adolescent, young adult, they, might be able to anticipate what concerns parents may have, they may have picked up that, oh my gosh, mom or dad are really concerned, about what others think about you know, having pink flamingos in the front of the house, so if they’re very concerned about, you know what others think, then maybe this might be a large area of concern for their parents. So this can, you know certainly, be a conversation starter, to understand these concerns.

Jonathan Singer: And I can imagine that if I were the kid, and I was coming out, and my parents were like, oh my God it’s all about me, that could be very disconnecting

Cynthia Conley: Yes

Jonathan Singer: but if I knew in advance, that their parents might be concerned about how their neighbors are going to react or you know are friends going to reject them, and I’m able to have that conversation with my therapist or my social worker, in advance that it wouldn’t be a disconnect, it would be a, oh, this is what Cyndi and I talked about, right, okay, yeah my parents are reacting, huh.

Cynthia Conley: Right, you know and there might you know the fact is that there may be, other, LGBT family members, somewhere that, if mom you know reacted you know in a positive manner to, finding out that Uncle Bill, was, gay, you can certainly, you know, estimate that okay well, you know maybe my, mom’s reaction to my own sexual orientation may not be a s bad, as what I anticipate.

Jonathan Singer: So Cyndi one of the things that, we always talk with social work students about, there’s a big push for social workers to know, why they’re doing what they’re doing. So you’ve just talked about these three areas, that would be important to, talk with parents about, but, you know how do I know that I should talk about these three areas and not, three other areas, or what makes these three areas legitimate, how did you come up with them? And why should social workers use them?

Cynthia Conley: Sure, that’s a great question Jonathan. Um, there’s three steps, really, I first went to the literature, and I reviewed, the research out there, that, was on parents reactions, to, learning about, having a gay or lesbian child, and you know, there was very little literature out there, on this particular area but, what I did, find it certainly supported my work in my practice, with LGBT individuals. And then I took this information and then I went and did some qualitative work in which I, conducted focus groups, with parents of, LGBT children who belonged or who attended PFLAG support meetings, and PFLAG Parents Families and Friends of Lesbians and Gays, because I wanted to see okay are these themes in the literature, and they still present, and um, that was very fruitful study, and from that information you know I did a, content analysis and um, on those themes and then I developed items, specific questions for, a scale actually of 55 items, and then I conducted a pilot study, of this scale, of the COPLAG scale on a national level, to, parents within PFLAG, who had an LGBT child. So that was the three steps taken, and so, in, in doing that of course with the statistical analysis, in doing various factor analysis I found that, these three, areas really clump together, these are the three predominant concern areas, that exist, it’s parents own concerns about, their own love loss, that’s, certainly, parents’ concerns about their child’s physical psychological and social well-being, and then the last, particular, cluster, factor, is really around, social desirability, in which I call “parent-ego”, it’ really about, oh my gosh, what is parent, what are what’s society going to think about me, because I’m a parent of a stigmatized child, so those are the three areas that kind of, really, you know shook out during all that statistical fun work.

Jonathan Singer: So you’ve created this scale, is this something that, social worker, would use with a parent right now, or a client?

Cynthia Conley: Eventually, yes

Jonathan Singer: Eventually, okay.

Cynthia Conley: eventually yes, I mean and I’m continuing you know, doing ongoing validation work and right now I’m in the process of doing a confirmatory factor analysis so that I can, certainly confirm these three areas, of concern, um, that exist you know, among this population, of actually parents who, are members or attend PFLAG. I’m also, um, confirming, you know these three concern areas I’m also confirming these, among different sample populations of parents, of LGBT children, who do not attend PFLAG. So, you know, so, certainly trying to access parents, you know, of LGBT children who do not go to support groups or, or therapy you know for this issue, but you know who can be accessed through various, for instance uh, gay-friendly churches or synagogues, so that I can, say alright, well this is these concern areas are pretty consistent, across you know various sample populations of parents.

Jonathan Singer: So it sounds like, these three areas that you are talking about are, based on, literature that you reviewed, focus groups, and then this, these psychometric techniques

Cynthia Conley: Yes

Jonathan Singer: About, um, these crazy statistics.

Cynthia Conley: Yes

Jonathan Singer: And through that it’s not that you set out to, say, oh, love loss, you know concerns about my kid, and, how society views my parenting, like those weren’t the three areas that you,

Cynthia Conley: No

Jonathan Singer: I’m going to create a scale and I’m going to test that and now I’ve proved it.

Cynthia Conley: No

Jonathan Singer: No, so this is what panned out.

Cynthia Conley: Yeah this is what panned out,

Jonathan Singer: Okay

Cynthia Conley: it’s you know 55 items and then when you, when you do the, you know the fun statistical analyses, this is what prevailed, it was you know three strong factors where, you have several items, you know there were four specific questions or items, that, aligned strongly, on, you know one factor, and that one particular factor when you look at what’s going on with these items, parents’ concerns that, they will you know, their loved ones will avoid them or that, they will be rejected by their parents, when you really look at the theme there, it’s around parents’ own, concerns that they’re going to lose love ones, because of having an LGBT child.

Jonathan Singer So the social workers that are out there that are listening to this, and are thinking oh, I would love to follow up with, you know this particular parent, on these three issues, um, can they, can they contact you?

Cynthia Conley: They can contact me and, you know and, you know as a practitioner, you know I would, certainly, you know if I was going to address one of the specific, areas of concern first, um, I would certainly address the parent’s concern over their child’s, physical psychological and social well-being, because it can be threatening to a parent, to be asked, are you just concerned about yourself, and not your child?

Jonathan Singer: And I mean when I think about, societal stigma about parents having a gay or lesbian kid or, loss of friends I mean that’s really, so much about the parents doing their own work,

Cynthia Conley: Um hm

Jonathan Singer: you know it’s like okay so, you know my, my 14 year old son whose gay, like he can’t control whether or not Aunt Betty, rejects me as the parent, you know and so, while it’s totally a reasonable and valid concern it’s very different than, this parental function of protecting my child and,

Cynthia Conley: Yes

Jonathan Singer: make sure that my child is able to, have a, sort of quote un quote normal, adolescence as possible,

Cynthia Conley: Right

Jonathan Singer: they seem to be very different,

Cynthia Conley: Yes

Jonathan Singer: yeah.

Cynthia Conley: That’s true, very good, that’s a great point yes they are they are very different, so, but um, you know, and they’re going to again they’re going to just vary, on the degree, but you know as far as the level of concern and the magnitude you know you’re going to find some parents who, are, very concerned that, that they’re going to lose friends, and you might, but on the other, you know particular concern areas, such as their, you know child’s, social well-being they’ll be extremely high or, um, vice versa, I mean there are some, you know I’ve seen some, parents’ responses in this pilot work where, you know, parents are not concerned that their child will be, you know verbally assaulted, but, you know they are, concerned that, society may consider them a parenting failure, for having a stigmatize child so, it’s, I have to tell you Jonathan it’s really kind of all over the place right now, you know, we don’t have a good enough grasp of what’s going on, and so, you know the development of the scale was really, a way to really start, you know bridging this gap in the extant literature, because, you know one of the things that you know and the goals that I really want to get to is, let’s look at some of the, you know factors that are going to predict, these parental reactions to learning about having a gay or lesbian child. You know, that’s where I really want to take this, because we don’t know, and so if we, can first you know figure out, what are the effective experiences, what are the feelings, what are the concerns, behind these reactions, if we can find, you know a little bit more out about, you know this particular area then maybe we can start building, towards okay, well, what kind of, can predict, you know, these concerns, what predicts these feelings, so.

Jonathan Singer: That sounds like uh, I’ll be interviewing you in a couple years about the predictors [chuckle]

Cynthia Conley: I would welcome that I would welcome that

Jonathan Singer: [chuckle] Just to wrap up because I think this is really important stuff, you were saying that there were three areas,

Cynthia Conley: Um hm, um hm

Jonathan Singer: that parents are concerned about…

Cynthia Conley: Yes, love loss, child well-being, and parent-ego. Parents are concerned about their own love loss, about their child’s physical, psychological, and social well-being, and the third area, the parent-ego is what I call it and, that and they are concerned about, what society thinks of them as parents, as a result of that, having a stigmatize child.

Jonathan Singer: Well Cyndi, thanks again for, for being here and talking with us about how to address parents’ concerns about having a gay or lesbian kid.

Cynthia Conley: Thank you so much Jonathan it’s been a pleasure and, certainly I hope that you’ll have me back in the future when I can, talk about the predictors, of parental reactions.

Jonathan Singer: I look forward to that.

Cynthia Conley: Great, thank you.

Jonathan Singer: I’m Jonathan Singer and thanks for being with me today for another episode of the Social Work Podcast. If you missed an episode, or have suggestions for future episodes, please visit http://www.socialworkpodcast.com. If you’d like to support the Podcast, please visit our online store at http://www.cafepress.com/swpodcast. To all the social workers out there keep up the good work, we’ll see you next time at the Social Work Podcast.

-- End --

References
Conley, C. (2011, forthcoming). The Development and Initial Validation of the COPLAG Scale: Measuring the Concerns of Parents of Lesbians and Gays. Journal of Gay and Lesbian Social Services.

Gibson, P. (1989), "Gay and Lesbian Youth Suicide", in Fenleib, Marcia R. (ed.), Report of the Secretary's Task Force on Youth Suicide, United States Government Printing Office, ISBN 0160025087

Ryan, C., Huebner, D., Diaz R. M., & Sanchez, J. (2009). Family Rejection as a Predictor of Negative Health Outcomes in White and Latino Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Young Adults. Pediatrics, 123, 346-352. Retreived from http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/full/123/1/346.

Homosexuality (n.d.). Wikipedia.org. Available at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homosexuality

Resources
Resources for Parents
Parents, Families and Friends of Lesbians and Gays (PFLAG)
1828 L Street, NW
Suite 660
Washington, D.C. 20036
Phone: (202) 467-8180
Fax: (202) 467-8194
General e-mail: info@pflag.org
Web: http://www.pflag.org/

Books for Parents
Straight Parents, Gay Children: Keeping Families Together
Robert A Bernstein, Thunder’s Mouth Press,2003

Straight Parents, Gay Children: Inspiring Families to Live Honestly and with Pride
Robert Bernstein, Thunder’s Mouth Press, 2003

Now That You Know
Betty Fairchild and Nancy Hayward. Harvest Books, 1998

Out of the Twilight: Fathers of Gay Men Speak
Andrew Gottlieb. Haworth Press, 2000

Beyond Acceptance: Parents of Lesbians and Gays Talk About Their Experiences
Griffen et al. St Martin’s Press, 1997

Different Daughters: A Book by Mothers of Lesbians
Louise Rafkin (ED). Cleis Press, 2001

Resource for LGBT adolescents/young adults
The GLBT National Youth Talkline (youth serving youth through age 25)
CONTACT INFO:
Toll-free 1-800-246-PRIDE (1-800-246-7743)
Email: youth@GLBTNationalHelpCenter.org


APA (6th ed) citation for this podcast: 

Singer, J. B. (Host). (2010, November, 5). Concerns of parents of lesbians and gays: Interview with Cynthia Conley, Ph.D. [Episode 62]. Social Work Podcast. Podcast retrieved Month Day, Year, from http://www.socialworkpodcast.com/2010/11/concerns-of-parents-of-lesbians-and.html

Posted in Labels: | 0 comments

Adoption Policy and Practice in the U.S.A.: Interview with Ruth McRoy, Ph.D.


[Episode 63] Today's Social Work Podcast is a broad overview of current policies and practices associated with adoption in the United States. According to the Evan B. Donaldson Institute, 6 in 10 Americans have had experience with adoption, meaning you, or a family member or close friend was adopted, adopted a child, or put a child up for adoption. Although most Americans have experience with adoption, as you'll hear in today's interview, the world of adoption is incredibly complex. For example, is it ever acceptable to consider the race of a prospective adoptive family when making placement decisions? For example, you're looking to place an African American child. You have three prospective adoptive families - two African American and one White. Assuming all things are equal, could you use race as an exclusionary criterion? What about if the child was White, Latino, or Native American? If you know the answer - congratulations. If not, keep listening. And even if you know the answer, keep listening.



My guest, Dr. Ruth McRoy, has been an academician, researcher, practitioner, trainer and lecturer in the field for over 30 years. She is a member of the North American Council on Adoptable Children (NACAC) Board and is a Senior Research Fellow and member of the Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute Board. In today's conversation, Ruth talks about different kinds of adoptions such as transracial, international, infant placement, and foster care adoption. She talks about the role of the social worker in adoption, from pre-placement to post-placement. She talks about some of the national and international laws that regulate adoption, such as the Multi-Ethnic Placement Act and the Indian Child Welfare Act. We end today's conversation with some resources that you can tap for more information about adoption, including the Evan B. Donaldson Institute, the National Resource Center for Adoption, AdoptUsKids.org, and the North American Counsel on Adoptable Children.

One quick word about today's Social Work Podcast: I recorded the interview with my Zoom H2 digital recorder. Ruth and I were sitting in an empty lecture hall at the Oregon Convention Center during the Annual Program Meeting of the Council on Social Work Education. Empty rooms are something of a commodity at conventions and I've done my best to edit out the sounds of people opening and closing the door looking for their own place to get some privacy. And now, without further ado, on to Episode 63 of the Social Work Podcast: Adoption Policy and Practice in the USA: Interview with Ruth McRoy, Ph.D.

Download MP3 [31:23]




Bio
Dr. McRoy has authored or co-authored eight books and more than 100 articles and book chapters on child welfare issues. Her recent honors include the 2004 Flynn Prize for Social Work Research from the University of Southern California, the 2005 George Silcott Lifetime Achievement Award from the Black Administrators in Child Welfare, and the 2006 Distinguished Achievement Award from the Society for Social Work and Research (SSWR).

An academician, researcher, practitioner, trainer and lecturer in the field for over 30 years, McRoy's work has focused on topics such as open adoptions, adoptive family recruitment, transracial identity development, family preservation, adolescent pregnancy, African American families, kinship care, and disproportionality in child welfare. She has received major research funding from public and private agencies such as the US Department of HHS, the Texas Department of Protective and Regulatory Services, and the Hogg Foundation. She is a member of the North American Council on Adoptable Children (NACAC) Board and is a Senior Research Fellow and member of the Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute Board.

Transcript

Jonathan Singer: Ruth thank so much for being here today and talking with us about adoption, and my first question for you is, what’s the current state of adoption?

Ruth McRoy: There are a number of different issues on adoption these days. When you think about the placement of a child that came from one set of parents placed with a family, non-biologically related as we have typically defined it, there are a number if different types of adoptions that we talk about. There may be trans-racial adoptions in which a child comes from one set of birth parents of a particular racial background, and is being placed with a family of a different racial background, for example an African American child being placed with a Caucasian adoptive family. There are also inter-country adoptions in which a child may be coming from one country, now being placed in a different country, maybe a child from China that is being adopted by a family from the U.S., or a child from South Africa who is being adopted by a family from Sweden. All kinds of things brings up a lot of different issues. There are also, now we’re talking in terms of infant placements, related to the age of the child, a very small child being placed after birth with adoptive families. There are children who have been removed from their birth families and placed in foster care, and when those children are adopted, those are typically referred to as foster care adoptions, adoptions from care, many of those are older child placements, some of those involve placements of sibling groups, some of those may be a trans-racial adoptions as well. Many of the infant adoptions are done by private agencies, sometimes by independent programs or attorneys. In addition to the infant placements and the foster care adoptions, now we are also having kinship adoptions, in which a related family member may adopt the child, whose parental rights have been terminated but relatives might adopt the child. There also foster parent adoptions in which individuals who have served as the child’s foster parents, now will legally adopt the child.

Jonathan Singer: So really it sounds like there are a lot of different kinds of adoptions.

Ruth McRoy: Yes there are, and within those kinds of adoption, there are differences in terms of opportunities for contact between birth and adoptive families. Historically, once the adoption papers were signed, there would be no further contact between birth and adoptive families, but now we have varying degrees of openness in adoption, which include the traditional more confidential adoption with no further contact. We also have mediated adoptions, in which there may be information that is transmitted between adoptive and birth families, but that non-identifiable information is typically transmitted through the agency, between the two parties. Some of those transmissions may be time-limited, which would suggest a time-limited mediated adoption in which that transfer of information is for a specified period of time. Or there may be ongoing, fully disclosed adoptions in which the adoptive parents and the birth parents are exchanging identifiable information with opportunity for ongoing face-to-face contact. Or maybe contact that is between the two parties, maybe by e-mail or postal mail, but it is direct and not through the agency. Sometimes those contacts are ongoing, and then sometimes they are time-limited; one party stops sending mail or making contact. There are also variations in terms of the persons involved in such contact; maybe it involves the birth mother, once in a while, from time to time, maybe the birth father is involved, and sometimes there are contacts in which birth grandparents, and similarly adoptive grandparents. So there are a lot of different dynamics that are ongoing in these, what we call kinship networks that are formed through adoption.

Jonathan Singer: So the complexity continues. So I guess my next question is, what is a social worker’s role in all of these various, permutations of adoption?

Ruth McRoy: Well there are a variety of different roles that social workers may play. First of all, if we’re talking about adoptions that are arranged through private agencies, the social worker typically is on staff of a private agency. The social worker may be involved in working with birth families, or it may be a specialized agency in which social workers just work with birth families. Other social workers may work with the adoptive families, and in those roles they may be preparing a birth parent for the placement of her child, maybe preparing both birth mother and birth father. The social worker may be working with adoptive parents, prospective adoptive parents, and that role sometimes involves the recruitment of those prospective parents, or the preparation of those prospective parents. They may be involved in offering a preparation class, or individual home visits and agency visits to study the family. They may or may not use a standardized home study assessment in order to assess the probability of that family being a good adoptive family. The next step of course, is once the adoptive family has been selected using the social worker’s and the agency’s standards for adoption, the social worker is involved in matching the characteristics of a family with the characteristics of the child. If it’s an infant, that may or may not involve looking at physical characteristics, looking at the preferences of the adoptive parents for the child they hope to adopt, related to the gender preference, age preference, or they may or may not be willing to accept a child with a disability. All of those are factors that are being considered, and similarly the birth parent may have her wish list for prospective adoptive parents, maybe a preference for a two parent family over a single parent, or it may not make a difference to that birth parent. The birth parent may have a preference for the child to be placed within race versus trans-racial, all kinds of factors might go into that decision making. Social workers also are often involved not only at pre-placement, but also in assisting the child and family in the adjustment once the child is in the home, and then post-placement after the adoption is finalized, typically around six months after the adoption depending on the state laws. Then there may be post-placement services that are provided to the family, it could be in the form of opportunities for returning to the agency for counseling, or involvement in the openness in adoption arrangement. If that is the case, the social worker may be involved in encouraging families to participate in support groups, all of these might be options. In a public agency adoption, there’s typically a number of social workers involved in a case, involving work with the birth family in which typically there has been a termination of parental rights, it is often is an involuntary termination of parental rights unlike the situation of the voluntary termination with private agencies. In many cases the social worker might be involved in working with the prospective adoptive family; preparing them, taking them through a training process, helping them identify the kind of child or children that they may adopt, preparing them for the adoption of maybe older children, developmentally what their needs might be, preparing the family to consider what impact it will have on the family. Perhaps as an example, a sibling group of two or five coming into the family, and the family is already parenting birth children or maybe fostering children, or maybe already has adoptive children, helping that family evolve in understanding the relationships and the impact on the existing relationships with new children joining the family who have a history of their own, a history with a birth family, maybe a history of being in the foster care system, maybe having moved multiple times, maybe having experienced multiple attachments through that process, and may be coming in with a variety of different needs. Similarly, the social worker would be involved as well with the provision of post-placement services which are very much needed, in helping the family acquire adoption subsidies if eligible for such subsidies to support that adoption, helping the family adjust, helping the child adjust, all of those are among the multiple roles social workers might play in each of those systems.

Jonathan Singer: So there are a lot of different kinds of adoptions, and sounds like there are roles that social workers play from pre-placement to post-placement, and everything in between, and I imagine that adoption is fairly regulated……

Ruth McRoy: Um hm

Jonathan Singer: ……and what are some of those regulations or laws that guide adoption practices?

Ruth McRoy: There are a variety of both state and federal laws that can guide adoption practice. There are in some states for example, laws that are prohibiting gay and lesbian adoptions, there are often proposals and some state legislation that may address some of those specific issues in terms of who can adopt. There are federal laws for example, the Multi-Ethnic Placement Act that was passed in 1994, the Inter-Ethnic provisions passed in 1996, which require diligent recruitment of families that are of the same racial and ethnic background as the children that are being placed, but also require that states not make placement decisions solely based on race. Those policies have a huge impact in terms of placement decision making in various states, those are federal laws.

Jonathan Singer: Can you give an example of what those laws might look like in practice?

Ruth McRoy: Yes. As an example, an interpretation of the Multi-Ethnic Placement Act that’s often made by agencies, is that since race is not to be considered, an agency can go out and recruit, but cannot just look at families of a particular racial background for a child. Let’s say they are seeking families for an African American child, they cannot limit consideration to just African American families, they must be open to all families that are making applications that have been approved to adopt, so race cannot be in any way a limiting consideration. Similarly, based upon the requirement within the Multi-Ethnic Placement Act for diligent recruitment, agencies must go out and look for families that are of a similar background but they cannot limit consideration to those families in making a decision about a particular child.

Jonathan Singer: And would that extend to religion?

Ruth McRoy: There are no existing federal laws that stipulate that a family has to belong to a particular background to match that of the child, no. There are other laws such as the Indian Child Welfare Act, which actually requires that agencies, and this law is very different from the Multi-Ethnic Placement Act, the Indian Child Welfare Act passed in 1978 requires agencies to seek first a family that is of the same tribe as the child that is available for adoption. If that cannot be done, the expectation is to seek a family of another tribe but still an Indian Native family. If that cannot be done, if and only then would you consider a non-Indian family, and what’s interesting about that is it’s a specific law pertaining to the adoption of Indian children which is very different from that of the Multi-Ethnic Placement Act. There are other policies, for example the Hague Treaty Impacts Inter-country adoptions, which is kind of interesting because within inter-country adoptions there’s an expectation that families are prepared for such adoptions, they have to go through a specified number of hours of training to prepare them for the adoption of a child from another country. That kind of requirement for training is not there, in the case of trans-racial adoptions, so depending upon the country of origin, the type of adoption if it’s inter-country, if the child is Native or Indian, those laws are different than a U.S. born child who specifically comes from typically interpreted as an African American child within the U.S.. Now the reality is that the Multi-Ethnic Placement Act should apply to all U.S. children, but it seems to be applied in practice more to African American children that are the group being adopted, often by White families. There are also a number of trans-racial adoptions, of Hispanic children into White families, we know that as a result of the experiences of many of these families that have trans-racially adopted, they have unique needs that they often seek opportunities for participation and support groups after the adoption through post-adoption services, recognizing that there are some unique challenges that they experience and they may not have been prepared for, prior to the adoption.

Jonathan Singer: So of course that bags the question, what are some of the supports they’re looking for, what are some of the experiences and some of the ways in which these families are not prepared, that if perhaps they were adopting a baby from Russia or China or some other country, they would have been required to be prepared.

Ruth McRoy: Um hm, um hm. There are a number of factors I should mention that agencies can offer a group, not mandated but can offer a group that would prepare families, but it cannot be solely offered to trans-racial parents, it has to be open to all families seeking to adopt, and that is different from the provision through Hague for inter-country adoptions, for families that typically need help with the child’s racial identity development, in the case of a trans-racial adoption. It is evident to the child and to others that that child is adopted because that child does not share the same phenotypic characteristics as the adoptive family, of course a child who does not share the same genotypic characteristics notices the differences. For example, often their skin color, their hair texture, and other physical characteristics are different than that of the family, they experience others around them often staring and asking questions, were you adopted? So this comes and children typically become aware of racial differences at an early age, typically around three or four years of age, and they often will ask questions. “Why is my skin brown and your skin is white?” “Why is my hair curly and your hair is straight?” They ask those questions, and they are asked that by their peers who will say, “Is that your real mommy?” “Is that your real daddy?” “You don’t look like them“. And the child is confronted with those kinds of things and then ask the parents. Parents often need help in trying to figure out, “How do I best explain this to the child at an early age?” “How do I explain about the adoption?” “How do I explain the racial difference?” Many of these families are living in communities in which the child may be the only one that has the characteristics that he or she might have and that becomes more evident, that the child is different from the family. Families often have questions about, “How do I reach out to a support group that looks like the child?” “How do I meet people within the community or outside of the community, so that this child has role models that look like him or her?” “How do I give this child an opportunity to play with other children that look like him or her because in this child’s school, that doesn’t exist“. So families typically have lots of questions related to this, “How do I answer the child’s questions about adoption, and the difference in racial identity?” Some families are seeking to have an opportunity to interact with other trans-racial adoptive families, “We want to talk with others who are experiencing the same kinds of things“. Some families are seeking very specific basic needs, trying to find, for example, a beautician that will be able to care for their child’s hair texture which may be different from the hair texture of parents. They sometimes are looking for someone to advise related to maybe something like dry skin, and not knowing who do I ask about those kinds of things. I talked with a family once who said, “We have no idea, do we just see some African American family walking around the grocery store and say would you help me?” “Would you help me with my child?“ As one family asked me one time, “Would you come by and sit with my child and expose the child to being African American because you’re the only one I know that looks like you, and looks like the child, how do I find those connections?” So many families have a lot of questions, and they often go back to the agency, and sometimes the agency will try to start a support group, and sometimes they might not. Many families who are trans-racially adopted, or maybe gay or lesbian, and so they have additional kinds of questions and issues that are being asked by the child in terms of not only racial identity, questions about gender and sexual identity, and the child often has questions that are raised to them, “Why do you have two mommies?”, “Why do you have two daddies?”, “Why do you have two mommies and two daddies that don’t look like you?”. They are of a different racial background, and the parents need to know that they can go to their family, with knowledge to be able to help them and address those questions.

Jonathan Singer: So we’ve talked about the different types of adoption, we’ve talked about the roles that social workers play, and you’ve just gone into some brief detail about trans-racial or multi-ethnic adoption, and I suspect that there are some listeners who might be hearing these ideas for the first time, and would love to know where to get more information, so can you suggest some resources for folks?

Ruth McRoy: Yes, there are a number of different websites that I would suggest, and parent groups. One I would mention is the North American Counsel on Adoptable Children, the acronym is NACAC, which has an annual conference each year typically in August, and brings together adoptive families they have provisions for children there, but it’s a wonderful opportunity for parents and professionals to get together and learn about many of the issues that I’ve been talking about. So again, that’s NACAC, on their website, nacac.org, lots and lots of good information. The Evan B. Donaldson Adoption Institute, out of New York City provides many well researched papers on it’s website, papers that are focused on such topics as the interpretation of the Multi-Ethnic Placement Act, the post-adoption services, lesbian and gay adoptions, many different papers are posted there, lots of good resources for families. In addition to those two entities, the website for All Children All Families provides excellent information for gay and lesbian adopters, similarly those topics are often discussed on the NACAC website and the Evan B. Donaldson Institute website. One that is sponsored by the U.S. Children’s Bureau is the Child Welfare Information Gateway, lots and lots of interesting links to all kinds of information about adoption, about foster care. The National Resource Center on Permanency and Family Connections, located at Hunter College, is again a federally funded project, it has many resources listed there on different types of adoption. The federally funded projects sponsored by the U.S. Children’s Bureau, called AdoptUsKids.org, is a wonderful resource for adoptive family members, not only for families who have adopted but for prospective adoptive families. Adopt Us Kids offers a photo listing website that includes children that are waiting for adoption, and families that are waiting for adoption, there are over 4,000 children listed, there are over 4,000 families listed, lots of good information and resource materials, such as a publication called Finding A Fit That Lasts A Lifetime, which is a wonderful resource document for agencies trying to find appropriate families for children available for adoption. Both the Child Welfare Information Gateway and Adopt Us Kids presents information about the numbers of children awaiting adoption, currently there are about 114,000 children available for adoption, about 70,000 of those are legally free for adoption, those are represented among the population of children in foster care which is around 466,000 at this point. Each year about 75,000 or so children are adopted from foster care. Information about those adoptions and about those children can be found on many of those websites that I’ve identified.

Jonathan Singer: That’s great, those are wonderful resources and I’ll make sure that we put them on the Social Work Podcast website so people can go link directly to them.

Ruth McRoy: There’s one more resource that I want to mention and that’s the National Resource Center for Adoption, and that is located in Spaulding, Michigan, again a federally funded initiative with lots and lots of excellent information There are opportunities for states to receive training in technical assistance at each of those resource centers, including the National Resource Center for Permanency, the National Resource Center for Adoption, and Adopt Us Kids, where consultants will go out into the states and work with state adoption managers and workers, focused on trying to find permanency for that large number of children in foster care that need adoptive families. Currently we have about 30,000 children who age out of the system, each year, who never achieved permanency through adoption. Large numbers of those children end up among the homeless population, many of those children end up in the criminal justice system, we have a great need to find families who wish to provide a permanent home for children in the system. So it’s extremely important for both public agency workers and private agency workers to partner, to increase the chances of those at this point, 114,000 children, that need to have a place to call home.

Jonathan Singer: Ruth thanks so much for talking with us today about this clearly urgent issue of adoption, for providing statistics and the real life aspects of why adoption is important for the kids, and is something that we should be considering as social workers who are involved in human rights and social justice. So thanks for being here.

Ruth McRoy: Thank you for inviting me, I enjoyed it.

--END--

References and Resources


APA (6th ed) citation for this podcast:

Singer, J. B. (Host). (2010, December 29). Adoption policy and practice in the U.S.A.: Interview with Ruth McRoy, Ph.D. [Episode 63]. Social Work Podcast. Podcast retrieved Month Day, Year, from http://socialworkpodcast.com/2010/12/adoption-policy-and-practice-in-usa.html

Posted in Labels: | 0 comments